Imperfection is the Character

A builder mentioned it in passing, while discussing a recently completed project. The client preferred the walls when they weren't plumb and the floors not so level.

It stopped me. Not because it was surprising, exactly, but because it named something that usually goes unsaid. A lot of time is spent in old buildings trying to fix the things that time has done to them. Here was someone who had noticed what time had done, and preferred it.

The walls in question are in a weatherboard cottage in Beechworth. Built in the 1860s, lived in almost continuously since, never quite important enough to attract the kind of money that would have straightened it out. The floors had almost gone. The wall frames had rotted at the floor junction. The walls leant away from the wind, in directions that no plumb line would approve.

I think there's a reason for that preference, even if the client never put it in these terms. A straight wall says nothing much. A wall that has moved tells you the building has been here long enough for the ground to move under it, for the timber to dry and twist, for a hundred and sixty years of summers and winters to work their way through the fabric. The imperfection is the character. I suspect that's what we respond to, even when we can't quite say why.

The cottage walls had been papered, re-papered, and papered again. Lino over floorboards. Iron over shingles. Each layer the decision of someone who was cold, or tired of looking at faded wallpaper, or who simply wanted the place to feel a bit better than it did. Nobody was thinking about heritage. They were thinking about this winter.

A carpenter's house, probably a succession of others like him. Each making the most practical decision available to them at the time. The layers survived because the money to do anything more thorough was never there. The result, a hundred and sixty years later, is something close to a stratigraphic record of how ordinary people actually lived. Not the version that ends up in history books, but the real one, incremental and pragmatic and largely invisible until someone pulls up the lino.

This is how most of the surviving physical evidence of goldfields life has come to us. Not preserved because anyone thought it worth preserving, but preserved because replacement was a luxury the occupants couldn't afford. The grand buildings got restored. The modest ones got left alone, and in being left alone, kept their evidence.

There's a concept in heritage practice called curated decay, developed by the geographer Caitlin DeSilvey, that argues for non-intervention as a legitimate heritage strategy. The idea is to allow buildings to continue changing rather than fixing them at an arbitrary point in time and calling that the truth of them. It's a useful framework. It doesn't mean neglect. It means making conscious decisions about what to let continue, and what to hold on to, based on some understanding of what the decay is actually telling you about the building.

The standard heritage response treats decay as the enemy. Arrest it, reverse it, conceal it. The assumption is that a building has a correct state, usually something close to its original construction, and that everything since is damage to be undone. But a building that has been lived in for a hundred and sixty years isn't damaged. It's life documented. The carpenter papered over the wall. The next family put lino down because it was warmer. The shingles were leaking so corrugated iron was nailed over the top of them. Each decision is a fact about how people lived, what they could afford, what they needed. Strip it back to the original and you've removed the evidence. It feels less like restoration and more like editing.

But fixed is not the same as erased. Maybe the question to ask before any intervention is this: what is this part saying? What does it say to you about the building, about the people who were here before, about the decisions they made and the constraints they were working within. If the intervention can work alongside that evidence, it should. If it can't, maybe it shouldn't?

You can't ask people to live in a building that is still falling down. In the Beechworth cottage, the walls got straightened. Not because anyone wanted to erase what time had done, but because the structure required it. Wall frames had rotted. The floors had almost gone.

That's the tension curated decay doesn't fully resolve, and I'm not sure it should. As a philosophy it works beautifully. As a practice the reality is that a house has to be lived in, and that sometimes means intervening in ways that remove the very evidence you wanted to keep. You ask the question, weigh it carefully, and sometimes the answer is still no.

What changes is the asking. The client who told the builder they preferred the walls when they weren't straight had noticed something real. That noticing deserves to be taken seriously, even when the outcome can't honour it. It means the next decision gets made with a little more care. It means you don't straighten a wall without knowing what you're losing.

Next
Next

Lake View through a child's eyes